heysoundude
Part of the Furniture
Cake charts to be selected as a viewing option in spdMerlin, perhaps?Oh boy - wouldn't this be sweet. I second, third and fourth this!
Cake charts to be selected as a viewing option in spdMerlin, perhaps?Oh boy - wouldn't this be sweet. I second, third and fourth this!
I would like it more if it was under the normal QoS tab with a option to toggle advanced settings.
is that you saying you're adding it or trying to lure me in to get my slice?
As it's much easier to modify settings now.
And this is/was the goal. Sorry @lilstone87 - when you were going through your stress, I did know where we were at with the mod, but was subtlety suggesting for patience at the time. A few days later hopefully you are smiling now.
No, because as soon as a user customizes them in our GUI, they become detached from the firmware defaults. The same fields are always written to the config though, so I don’t believe it’s an issue. Do you see something different happening?Do you think it would be better to automatically include the default ULOPTIONS and DLOPTIONS into the cake-qos.add file, and then just append the ones that have been applied from the GUI? (ie. ULOPTIONS="$ULOPTIONS <moreoptions")
This was in the works, but cut out of the initial release due to the pressing need for basic customizations. But it will completely depend on moving Cake from ifb4eth0 to br0 (which was also in the works). It makes iptables much easier than skbedit. Miles to go...Also (and I know I keep harping on about this), has anyone done any experimentation to get DSCP marking applied to the download queue?
I'll admit that while I can more or less make out what is happening in the OpenWRT implementation, I am struggling to find the energy to work out how it would be adapted to the Merlin firmware.
It only means that the proper place to change the bandwidth is on the main QoS page. It is in display-only mode on CakeQoS page. But AutoBW/spdMerlin will work fine.I see (Read Only) in the screenshot in the first post behind Bandwidth. Does that mean it does or does not work with AutoBW in spdMerlin?
So I do see that theDo you think it would be better to automatically include the default ULOPTIONS and DLOPTIONS into the cake-qos.add file, and then just append the ones that have been applied from the GUI? (ie. ULOPTIONS="$ULOPTIONS <moreoptions")
ingress
keyword gets dropped because, well, I forgot about it. So your idea may be the right approach. I’ll have to review the code again.It’s part of removing the ifb4eth0 device during QoS restart. Not a problem.Just getting this error in the log:
Mar 19 13:58:12 CakeQOS-Merlin: Configuring Cake options...
Mar 19 13:58:12 lldpd[1020]: removal request for address of fe80::c75:55ff:fef4, but no knowledge of it
What does that mean?
The code is there but hidden because it was too complicated for the initial release, based on the complexity discussed in the other thread. And I wanted to wait for beta2. Who are you at OpenWRT.org?The only thing missing is the option that allows changing to a different interface for download or upload (wan, lan, br0, etc)
Who are you at OpenWRT.org?
Thanks for this great work @ttgapers , @dave14305 and others too I suspect.If you were running the 1.0.8 script, you need to stop cake-qos first in case of a conflict with ifb9eth0 and the firmware ifb4eth0
It’s still an Add-on that only requires the script and the firmware. No extra packages.so, this v2 would be native on 386.2 final?
The 1.0.x version should be uninstalled. We may add an uninstall of the old packages when we get to the beta phase.This looks amazing. I would like to clarify a few things, though.
Am I understanding everything correctly?
- We do not need cake-qos installed to use this script; it is based on Cake built into 386.2 Beta 1?
- This replaces and adds additional features to, @dave14305 's example.
- We can not perform RMerlin's Cake Test because this will overwrite his suggestions?
The latter.One question: does this replace the now built-in cake? Or is more like a way to configure the built-in cake with more options?
You can add those less common options in the Custom text box.On previous cake threads I saw a good amount of discussion around adjusting rtt values, and indeed, I have been fiddling with mine. Any chance of adding that configuration here?
Welcome To SNBForums
SNBForums is a community for anyone who wants to learn about or discuss the latest in wireless routers, network storage and the ins and outs of building and maintaining a small network.
If you'd like to post a question, simply register and have at it!
While you're at it, please check out SmallNetBuilder for product reviews and our famous Router Charts, Ranker and plenty more!