Not to hijack the thread but the unsolicited advice has prompted a question. I have the 6141 modem with the 8 downstream channels and have had the Comcast 105/20 service for a while now. I typically get speedtest speeds of around 122/22 but recently in the past month or so I've been consistently getting 126/24. I know Comcast is known to bump the speeds for a particular speed tier without warning. Is it possible they have bumped the speeds in my market and my modem is now the bottleneck?
I've done some research (dslreports forums) and there is a distinct possibility that they have raised the speeds in my area to 150/20. Is it time for me to buy a new 16x4 modem? Thanks and sorry for hijacking.
Doc,
You don't mention where you are located, but with the impending TWC acquisition by Comcast, both have been upgrading their services in major metro areas like mad. If you're in Los Angeles, New York, Chicago, Dallas, Atlanta, or some other major metro area served by one or the other of these carriers, there's a good chance you've been upgraded to higher speeds. One sure sign that service has been upgraded to higher tiers is that your cable TV has been converted to all-digital (i.e., no more analog channels), because part of the 16-channel bonding requirement (or so I've been told) is that they must use that same bandwidth on their systems to allow them to moving to all QAM256, so they can bond those channels for internet service.
I suggest you call Comcast's technical support and ask. They should be able to tell you if your area has been upgraded recently and whether it now supports the 16-channel bonding required for speeds above 120 Mbps. I believe you'll also find that both TWC and Comcast have been pushing out both the Arris-Motorola SB6183 cable modems as well as the Arris DT1670A combo modem-router-wireless units, which are the only 16x4 cable modem units used by these two ISP's as far as I know (from reading both their own message forums and DSLReports). So if you have the higher service, there's a good chance you can just lease a new cable modem from them directly.
if you want buy a cable modem, there is really only one option at the moment: The Arris DT1670A combo unit is NOT available for retail, but is only provide to ISP's for lease. There is a Netgear combo unit which is capable of 16x4 (sorry, I forgot the model number) but no one ever has that thing in stock, so as a practical matter, the only real choice is the Arris Motorola SB6183 that Best Buy sells for $129.00. It's also available from others on Amazon, but at a huge markup, because of the scarcity of this model. Best Buy does stock them, you just have to check online to see which stores are carrying them and have a supply at any given moment.
On the subject of buying a new SB6183 (16x4) to replace your SB6141 (8x4) vs. leasing, even though I bought mine as soon as TWC upgraded my area to 300/20 (well, not right away...I did lease an Arris DG1670A for about two weeks but didn't like it), in hindsight I think it probably doesn't pay to buy and it's cheaper and easier to just lease one from your ISP. For example, TWC leases their cable modems for $4.00 a month. Buying one costs a minimum of $129, and with the sales tax and electronic recycling fees charged in California, I wound up paying over $140.
It doesn't take much effort to calculate that for what I paid, I could have just leased for 3 years, and then when the next and better modem comes out, just lease the new model all over again and not be stuck with an outdated modem. I would still have the cash in my pocket and at any point along the way, I could have exchanged it for something newer and better, or replaced it if it crapped out. Now if mine dies, I have to either buy a new one, or lease from my cable company. You know, buying isn't always the best option when you're dealing with a depreciating piece of equipment that will eventually either die or be replaced for something better. Too bad nobody leases ASUS routers....lol.
Oh, and I completely agree with Merlin that a 2 or 3 Mbps swing in upload/ download internet speed using an online speed test is not indicative of very much, if anything.