maxbraketorque
Very Senior Member
Here is what I see, AC86U and AX86U compared side by side to test AC clients at the same locations - same room 3m away, behind one wall 10m away and behind 2 walls 15m away, plus some more differences:
- AX86U shows 4dBm lower signal strength from clients on all channels, perhaps less sensitive radio.
- AC86U can do >60Mbps real transfers on channels 36-48, but no more than 40Mbps on 149-161.*
- AX86U can do >60Mbps real transfers on channels 149-161, but no more than 40Mbps on 32-48.*
- 2.4GHz band is exactly the same on both, same dBm reported and same transfer speeds.
- despite the dBm differences on 5GHz band, I would say both routers have identical performance to AC clients, just need to be set differently.
- I tried to crash AX86U with my test transfer to USB attached SSD and it survived, AC86U doesn't. I've seen this on AX88U though - 1GB RAM.
- AX86U LEDs are much brighter than the LEDs on AC86U - a bit uncomfortable, if the router is used in a dark room.
- AX86U WAN LED blinks differently when WAN port is used and when 2.5GbE port is used for WAN. I like 2.5GbE port LED better.
- Asus App can't restore AX86U LEDs after turned off, no LAN LEDs coming up. Works in Asuswrt-Merlin GUI though. Minor inconvenience.
* - Wi-Fi environment specific
I have the router for few days only and had no much time to play with it. The case is a bit cheap plasticky looking, the antennas were not aligned perfectly and needed slight force adjustment. Acceptable for $250 router though with good hardware inside. I like the normal power jack and the new switch, but there is a design flaw - on/off switch is at the wrong side of the power jack and is too close to it. It's a bit hard to reach.
I had to open a new thread for this comparison information, apologies @Oracle.
Thanks for the comparison. I guess I can stop contemplating purchasing an AX86U, at least for the wifi performance. There will be an edge for router VPN performance.
The LEDs can be made dimmer by coloring over them with a black Sharpie. Still visible, but much dimmer. It works great.