What's new

Outgoing routing fails after WAN IP address rotates

  • SNBForums Code of Conduct

    SNBForums is a community for everyone, no matter what their level of experience.

    Please be tolerant and patient of others, especially newcomers. We are all here to share and learn!

    The rules are simple: Be patient, be nice, be helpful or be gone!

Pila

Regular Contributor
After my provider rotates my WAN IP address, my router as a rule (but not allways) looses ability to route any devices (LAN and WLAN) out to the Internet. At the same time, inbound connections work perfectly and the router itself sees and uses the Internet perfectly OK. Inet is up 24/7 and it is at a remote location.

I have USB 3G modem connected to Asus RT-AC56U fw Asuswrt-Merlin RT-AC56U_380.59_0. Possible idea of it drawing too much power is wrong: it draws maximally 170 ma (measured), and that is absolutely below any USB risk level. Changing the modem's position to vertical at 2 m height does not influence anything, so no signal problem there.

My provider rotates address once in 1 or 2 days, most often at the similar time early before the morning. I have seen them rotating after an hour. I can not do anything there.

Router works perfectly. When after some time my WAN IP address gets rotated, router sees that new IP address normally. ping -c1 8.8.8.8 | grep "packets received" sees no problems, curl -s http://icanhazip.com and wget -q --spider http://google.com work OK.

Router displays WAN IP address OK. Router updates both my DDNS services with the new IP address OK. Router sends me an e-mails about the new WAN IP address OK. I can connect to my VPN server created by the router. From outside, I can connect perfectly using that VPN to my local: server, to Raspberry or Camera. I can normally communicate with them and get desired data from them using VPN server at the Router. I can connect VPN client from that router to another VPN server.

But.... Inside the network, I can not get to the Internet. All my LAN devices - that same Raspberry, server or Camera do not see the Internet. My PC and phone as WLAN devices do not see the Internet. I tried WEB, NTP, file transfers, e-mail...

So, my guess is that something is wrong with IP tables inside the router and that it does not do what is needed after my WAN IP address rotates.

On ocassions, I can find the problem using internal check:

ip route | grep "default"

or external one:

wget -q -4 --spider http://google.com

But, sometimes, as today, they just do not see anythinng is wrong. As I said, my router has perfectly sucessfully sent me 2 e-mails with new IP address after they were assigned to my two DDNS services. Sometimes, one of these two commands do realize there is no Internet and then I reboot the modem. After the reboot, almost always all is perfect again.

I could try checking the Internet from another device and then communicate to my Router to reboot. But, this is overkill. I will try using an USB modem which will put my router after a double nat so that the routing between the router and modem never needs to be changed. But, that may introduce a new set of problems (going from a single nat to the double nat).

But, I would prefer if my Router would work as expected.
 
After my provider rotates my WAN IP address, my router as a rule (but not allways) looses ability to route any devices (LAN and WLAN) out to the Internet. At the same time, inbound connections work perfectly and the router itself sees and uses the Internet perfectly OK. Inet is up 24/7 and it is at a remote location.

I have USB 3G modem connected to Asus RT-AC56U fw Asuswrt-Merlin RT-AC56U_380.59_0. Possible idea of it drawing too much power is wrong: it draws maximally 170 ma (measured), and that is absolutely below any USB risk level. Changing the modem's position to vertical at 2 m height does not influence anything, so no signal problem there.

My provider rotates address once in 1 or 2 days, most often at the similar time early before the morning. I have seen them rotating after an hour. I can not do anything there.

Router works perfectly. When after some time my WAN IP address gets rotated, router sees that new IP address normally. ping -c1 8.8.8.8 | grep "packets received" sees no problems, curl -s http://icanhazip.com and wget -q --spider http://google.com work OK.

Router displays WAN IP address OK. Router updates both my DDNS services with the new IP address OK. Router sends me an e-mails about the new WAN IP address OK. I can connect to my VPN server created by the router. From outside, I can connect perfectly using that VPN to my local: server, to Raspberry or Camera. I can normally communicate with them and get desired data from them using VPN server at the Router. I can connect VPN client from that router to another VPN server.

But.... Inside the network, I can not get to the Internet. All my LAN devices - that same Raspberry, server or Camera do not see the Internet. My PC and phone as WLAN devices do not see the Internet. I tried WEB, NTP, file transfers, e-mail...

So, my guess is that something is wrong with IP tables inside the router and that it does not do what is needed after my WAN IP address rotates.

On ocassions, I can find the problem using internal check:

ip route | grep "default"

or external one:

wget -q -4 --spider http://google.com

But, sometimes, as today, they just do not see anythinng is wrong. As I said, my router has perfectly sucessfully sent me 2 e-mails with new IP address after they were assigned to my two DDNS services. Sometimes, one of these two commands do realize there is no Internet and then I reboot the modem. After the reboot, almost always all is perfect again.

I could try checking the Internet from another device and then communicate to my Router to reboot. But, this is overkill. I will try using an USB modem which will put my router after a double nat so that the routing between the router and modem never needs to be changed. But, that may introduce a new set of problems (going from a single nat to the double nat).

But, I would prefer if my Router would work as expected.

Sounds like what'd been happing to me with my AC1900p on the lastest FW .62


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
So, nobody is finding any interest regarding this apparant Bug?

I must say there are so many problems with Asus routers that it is getting tiresome trying to naviage aroudn them all.
 
Easy way to reproduce an error is to just pull the USB modem out and put it back in. Modem will redial.

Sometimes, I can do it several times in a row with no ill results. Just now, all it took was to pull it out once and return it. No routing to the Internet by my router, but the Interet works perfectly from the router on.

I could even connect from outside with the VPN and pull picture from the camera!

From another local computer, ping works, but following fail:

curl -s http://icanhazip.com
wget --spider http://google.com

When I try to open a Web site from my PC, router puts up the Router login page.

Funny thing: after I replug the modem again, router manages to route normally again.
 

Similar threads

Support SNBForums w/ Amazon

If you'd like to support SNBForums, just use this link and buy anything on Amazon. Thanks!

Sign Up For SNBForums Daily Digest

Get an update of what's new every day delivered to your mailbox. Sign up here!
Top