moroi01
New Around Here
Maybe a dead thread but a follow-up of my experience maybe helps others.
Almost April 2023 - NetGear R7800 - working flawlessly for 4 years, latest 2 years working with Voxel + Kamoj on top, 2 different Voxel builds upgraded one year apart. I think first flash of Voxel was sometimes in beginning of 2021, latest and running currently at beginning of 2022. (I'm 99% sure it was V1.0.2.91SF version)
Today i woke up with router reset to factory settings, after a power outage (but I have a UPS upstream of router i don't think it actually lost power, that was the only "extraordinary" event, not sure if impacted or not, just putting on the table)
What i did recently (and corelated after reading this whole thread...YES i read all 13 pages of this thread) i insert a flash drive inside router to test something. Flash drive was inserted 1 month ago, forgot about it, (no metrics activated). Could be or could not be corelated.
What I did and didn't work so far (although I'm an IT engineer (virtualization mostly) i got limited knowledge in linux shell and router firmware)
- try to manually load the config saved beforehand. Did a power cycle ---> Restore to defaults
- restored some settings by hand. Did a power cycle ---> Restore to defaults
- try to upgrade the voxel firmware, today latest version at the moment I'm writing this, is V1.0.2.101SF, did some settings by hand. Did a power cycle ---> Restore to defaults
- try to downgrade to previous voxel firmware (thinking that maybe the latest beta is broken). Did some settings by hand. Did a power cycle ---> Restore to defaults
- I'm from romania and is winter here, i even kept the router outside few hours in cold, to address that heating problem (I'm refering to some colleague that wrote he kept the router unpluged for few days, and while waiting for warranty exchange, and !surprise! started to work)
- I flashed the latest NetGear stock firmware, at the moment writing this is V1.0.2.92. Did some settings by hand. Did a power cycle ---> Restore to defaults
- Back to latest voxel V1.0.2.101SF, and did that FULL NVRAM clear seen in this thread. Reboot. Did some settings by hand. Did a power cycle ---> Restore to defaults
What i did, AND WORKED (reading blocks write limit found in the comments of people like @HELLO_wORLD or @verbage or @kamoj (shout out for your plugin bro, many thanks for your work) I flashed DD-WRT (after one intermediary step, going back to stock) and all my settings are saved. Less performance than VOXEL, but at least 200 Euros (money for a new router) are remaining in my pocket for now and my family is not going crazy. Sorry, i tried, i saw that you check the chips vendors and all geeky stuff, and some of you are sending the equipment back to warranty, but those are not valid solutions for me.
This is not to say that DD-WRT is superior to Voxel, in my not-so-expert opinion, i think is a situation with the exact portion of the storage/MTD that the firmware is occupying and simply stock firmware and Voxel are using the same portion and both coming with same bugs, but let's will take this with a grain of salt.
Other firmware (I currently installed DD-WRT v3.0-r52189, i saw other people here installing Open WRT) are fixing this annoying issue but you have to deal with less performance from your NG R7800.
Almost April 2023 - NetGear R7800 - working flawlessly for 4 years, latest 2 years working with Voxel + Kamoj on top, 2 different Voxel builds upgraded one year apart. I think first flash of Voxel was sometimes in beginning of 2021, latest and running currently at beginning of 2022. (I'm 99% sure it was V1.0.2.91SF version)
Today i woke up with router reset to factory settings, after a power outage (but I have a UPS upstream of router i don't think it actually lost power, that was the only "extraordinary" event, not sure if impacted or not, just putting on the table)
What i did recently (and corelated after reading this whole thread...YES i read all 13 pages of this thread) i insert a flash drive inside router to test something. Flash drive was inserted 1 month ago, forgot about it, (no metrics activated). Could be or could not be corelated.
What I did and didn't work so far (although I'm an IT engineer (virtualization mostly) i got limited knowledge in linux shell and router firmware)
- try to manually load the config saved beforehand. Did a power cycle ---> Restore to defaults
- restored some settings by hand. Did a power cycle ---> Restore to defaults
- try to upgrade the voxel firmware, today latest version at the moment I'm writing this, is V1.0.2.101SF, did some settings by hand. Did a power cycle ---> Restore to defaults
- try to downgrade to previous voxel firmware (thinking that maybe the latest beta is broken). Did some settings by hand. Did a power cycle ---> Restore to defaults
- I'm from romania and is winter here, i even kept the router outside few hours in cold, to address that heating problem (I'm refering to some colleague that wrote he kept the router unpluged for few days, and while waiting for warranty exchange, and !surprise! started to work)
- I flashed the latest NetGear stock firmware, at the moment writing this is V1.0.2.92. Did some settings by hand. Did a power cycle ---> Restore to defaults
- Back to latest voxel V1.0.2.101SF, and did that FULL NVRAM clear seen in this thread. Reboot. Did some settings by hand. Did a power cycle ---> Restore to defaults
nvram default
nvram commit
mtd erase netgear
reboot
What i did, AND WORKED (reading blocks write limit found in the comments of people like @HELLO_wORLD or @verbage or @kamoj (shout out for your plugin bro, many thanks for your work) I flashed DD-WRT (after one intermediary step, going back to stock) and all my settings are saved. Less performance than VOXEL, but at least 200 Euros (money for a new router) are remaining in my pocket for now and my family is not going crazy. Sorry, i tried, i saw that you check the chips vendors and all geeky stuff, and some of you are sending the equipment back to warranty, but those are not valid solutions for me.
This is not to say that DD-WRT is superior to Voxel, in my not-so-expert opinion, i think is a situation with the exact portion of the storage/MTD that the firmware is occupying and simply stock firmware and Voxel are using the same portion and both coming with same bugs, but let's will take this with a grain of salt.
Other firmware (I currently installed DD-WRT v3.0-r52189, i saw other people here installing Open WRT) are fixing this annoying issue but you have to deal with less performance from your NG R7800.