I'll try it...Try to keep your VLAN ID's above 10 - many routers use internal VLAN's below that value to facility the routing inside (Guest Network, DMZ's for example)...
Best practice is to go above VLAN100...
VLAN100 did not work either...I'll try it...
These are great articles, thanks.Give it a try - the GS108T is a decent managed switch...
http://kb.netgear.com/24754/What-is-VLAN-Routing
http://kb.netgear.com/24755/How-do-I-configure-VLAN-Routing-on-a-smart-switch
And a third party perspective that may be related to what you would like to do
http://riceball.com/d/content/vlans-netgear-gs108t
I think its the GS7xx series. Not in my league.These are great articles, thanks.
Do you now which Netgear switch is covered by Step 6 "how to I configure VLAN Routing on a smart switch"?
http://kb.netgear.com/24755/How-do-I-configure-VLAN-Routing-on-a-smart-switch
The screen shots of the Routing > IP > IP Configuration screen does not appear to be the GS108Tv2.
Thanks.
I'm seeing the exact same problem as you, with a Linksys LGS308. I've been told by Netgear that the GS108Tv2 should work as long as the all devices are on the same subnet and have static IPs. But apparently it does not work... but hope we can get an answer to this problem.I would first of all like to thank the author for these 2 great articles. There are tons of general guides and manuals about VLANs these days, but those two are probably the only one that actually in details describe the actual implementation on most known consumer/SOHO switches.
I did manage to get the tagged VLANs (802.1Q) working with DHCP, mutiple switches AND VLAN-aware router - the whole shebang. However, I tried to poke around the simple setup with not vlan-aware router and no tagging and....it just didn't work :O
I basically followed this guide:
https://www.smallnetbuilder.com/lan...how-to-segment-a-small-lan-using-tagged-vlans
and my setup is following:
router<--port1-->switch<---port4-->PC
vlan1 contains all 8 ports untagged
vlan 2 contains port 1+4 untagged
port 4 PVID = vlan2
In other words, exactly, as in the guide.
1. DHCP isn't leasing me any IPs - I get APIPA
2. Even with static IP (incl. router as gateway), I cannot ping either the router itself or anything else....
All the devices are on the same subnet.
Switch is a Netgear108Tv2 with the latest firmware (5.4.2.27)
What am I doing wrong ??
Yes, the author mentions, that it's a GS108Tv1 switch. I just don't get it, that then means, that Netgear has just removed the portVLAN functionality in the V2 release, which just doesn't make sense, or it's just a bug they don't care to fix.I'm seeing the exact same problem as you, with a Linksys LGS308. I've been told by Netgear that the GS108Tv2 should work as long as the all devices are on the same subnet and have static IPs. But apparently it does not work... but hope we can get an answer to this problem.
Example 2 in the article I believe was done with the GS108Tv1, since I could not find the setup screen, which allows for a VLAN TYPE = IEEE 802.1Q setting (vs Type = Port), in the GS108tV2 manual. I wonder if something in the firmware has changed between the GS108Tv1 vs GS108Tv2?
Welcome To SNBForums
SNBForums is a community for anyone who wants to learn about or discuss the latest in wireless routers, network storage and the ins and outs of building and maintaining a small network.
If you'd like to post a question, simply register and have at it!
While you're at it, please check out SmallNetBuilder for product reviews and our famous Router Charts, Ranker and plenty more!