If I am going to change NICs I want to use 10 gig NICs. No reason to stop at 2.5 gig since I am starting new. I might as well buy 10 gig NICs as 2.5 gig.
Hmm, I dunno. If you're allergic to fan noise then insisting on 10G is kind of counterproductive, because all the available hardware of that speed runs hot. I've not seen much if any gear that is fanless and has more than two 10G-capable ports. That might change before too much longer, but it seems to be reality today.