spdMerlin spdMerlin - v4.x - speedtest and bandwidth monitoring

[ExtremeFiretop]

Bingo I just recreated the problem but no idea how exactly lol:

I just reconfigured the client to be restricted and then used the external binary instead of built-in

 

[Martinski]

Bingo I just recreated the problem but no idea how:
....
I just reconfigured the client to be restricted and then used the external binary instead of built-in

Something is preventing the router from connecting to the Ookla server via the WireGuard interface.

 

[ExtremeFiretop]

Something is preventing the router from connecting to the Ookla server via the WireGuard interface.

Agreed.

@aex.perez and @fsb

I configured the Wireguard client to have NAT disabled. Inbound Firewall to block. And then added an optional DNS server. With VPN killswitch enabled.

Then configured the spdMerlin script to use the external binary, basically the worst case scenario, and got the error.

So next question would be do you have any of those configured by chance?

 

[ExtremeFiretop]

Slowly been doing process of elimination; Seems to be related to the NAT setting (at least for me)
Whenever I disable it I get the error; right now at this moment my internet works; every other setting is removed, and I'm still getting the error.

As soon as I re-enable the NAT it starts working again:

Here are some "related" sys logs showing the difference between the working and non-working tests a 1 minute apart:

Mar 12 07:32:57 spdMerlin: Speedtest results - Download: 1055.01 Mbps (data used: 1.8 GB ) - Upload: 561.53 Mbps (data used: 540.4 MB )
Mar 12 07:32:57 kernel: br53: port 12(wds3.1.1.52) entered blocking state
Mar 12 07:32:57 kernel: br53: port 12(wds3.1.1.52) entered disabled state
Mar 12 07:32:57 kernel: device wds3.1.1.52 entered promiscuous mode
Mar 12 07:32:57 kernel: br53: port 12(wds3.1.1.52) entered blocking state
Mar 12 07:32:57 kernel: br53: port 12(wds3.1.1.52) entered forwarding state
Mar 12 07:32:57 spdMerlin: Connection quality - Latency: 11.59 ms (0.29 ms jitter) - Packet Loss: 3.0%
Mar 12 07:32:58 spdMerlin: Retrieving data for WebUI charts...
Mar 12 07:32:58 kernel: Assigning idx[100] for wds3.1.1.53
Mar 12 07:32:58 kernel: netdev path : wds3.1.1.53 -> wds3.1.1
Mar 12 07:32:58 kernel: BCMVLAN : wds3.1.1 mode was set to RG
Mar 12 07:32:58 kernel: br58: port 13(wds3.1.1.53) entered blocking state
Mar 12 07:32:58 kernel: br58: port 13(wds3.1.1.53) entered disabled state
Mar 12 07:32:58 kernel: device wds3.1.1.53 entered promiscuous mode
Mar 12 07:32:58 kernel: br58: port 13(wds3.1.1.53) entered blocking state
Mar 12 07:32:58 kernel: br58: port 13(wds3.1.1.53) entered forwarding state
Mar 12 07:33:01 kernel: wfd_unregisterdevice Successfully unregistered ifidx 2 wfd_idx 1
Mar 12 07:33:01 kernel: br0: port 15(wds1.1.1.0) entered disabled state
Mar 12 07:33:01 kernel: br53: port 10(wds1.1.1.52) entered disabled state
Mar 12 07:33:01 kernel: device wds1.1.1 left promiscuous mode
Mar 12 07:33:01 kernel: br58: port 12(wds1.1.1.53) entered disabled state
Mar 12 07:33:01 kernel: Freeing devid[2137] for wds1.1.1
Mar 12 07:33:01 kernel: Freeing devid[2138] for wds1.1.1.0
Mar 12 07:33:01 kernel: br0: port 15(wds1.1.1.0) entered disabled state
Mar 12 07:33:01 kernel: Freeing devid[2139] for wds1.1.1.52
Mar 12 07:33:01 kernel: br53: port 10(wds1.1.1.52) entered disabled state
Mar 12 07:33:01 kernel: Freeing devid[2140] for wds1.1.1.53
Mar 12 07:33:01 kernel: br58: port 12(wds1.1.1.53) entered disabled state
Mar 12 07:33:01 kernel: ^[[0;33;41m[ERROR vlan] vlanIoctl ,668: Failed to delete VLAN device wds1.1.1.52^[[0m
Mar 12 07:33:01 kernel: ^[[0;33;41m[ERROR vlan] vlanIoctl ,668: Failed to delete VLAN device wds1.1.1.0^[[0m
Mar 12 07:33:02 kernel: ^[[0;33;41m[ERROR vlan] vlanIoctl ,668: Failed to delete VLAN device wds1.1.1.53^[[0m
Mar 12 07:33:02 kernel: ^[[0;33;41m[ERROR vlan] vlanIoctl ,668: Failed to delete VLAN device wds1.1.1.0^[[0m
Mar 12 07:33:06 kernel: SBF: dhd1: INIT [00:41:0e:23:06:27] ID 65535 BFW 65535 THRSH 2048
Mar 12 07:33:19 spdMerlin: Starting speedtest using auto-selected server for WGVPN1 interface
Mar 12 07:33:37 SIG_UPDATE: current sig : 2448
Mar 12 07:33:37 SIG_UPDATE: latest sig : 2448
Mar 12 07:33:43 spdMerlin: Error running speedtest for WGVPN1

Edit:

Issuing a service restart_dnsmasq or a service restart_wgc does not resolve the issue as long as NAT is disabled for me.
Switching to the internal (built-in) binary has not resolved it either.

 

[aex.perez]

N/A to me
Not the client, am the server or servers in my case (Opensense, Wireguard and IPsec)

 

[ExtremeFiretop]

N/A to me
Not the client, am the server or servers in my case (Opensense, Wireguard and IPsec)

Okay, no worries.

It would be unrelated to my new Wireguard code then so all I can hope is maybe @fsb can confirm over his Wireguard client if he has those options enabled or disabled while testing.