Unfortunately i don't have NAS device or use LAN to LAN sharing so cannot help you with that, sorry.@exoxon
Since it seems you are one of the only other person in this forum that use the AX86U with QOS, do you by chance see the reduction in LAN to LAN transfers when you enable traditional QOS or Cake?
I have a NAS that I use for file sharing and whenever I enable Cake or traditional QOS my transfer speed to and from my local NAS drops from ~100MB down to ~60MBs
The thread subject is no longer valid... heh heh.Dirty upgrade from Alpha (drop 2) to Alpha2. Slick as a whistle.
I guess I'm really the outlier, I quess I could switch back to the AC86 that works with QOS without impacting internal LAN transfers, even though I lose faster wifiUnfortunately i don't have NAS device or use LAN to LAN sharing so cannot help you with that, sorry.
This is VERY interesting to myself because... I am currently Transitioning from using a RT-AC68U & FlexQoS as my primary router + a single RT-AC68U Mesh Node... to using a RT-AX86U as Primary & likely using CAKE with one or two RT-AC68U Mesh Nodes. Anyways if you were using FlexQoS with Adaptive I would probably point out that you could probably make the NAS device a higher QoS class because as you described above... depending on what you were doing, wouldn't the device be correct in classifying the the NAS activity as file-transfer@exoxon
Since it seems you are one of the only other person in this forum that use the AX86U with QOS, do you by chance see the reduction in LAN to LAN transfers when you enable traditional QOS or Cake?
I have a NAS that I use for file sharing and whenever I enable Cake or traditional QOS my transfer speed to and from my local NAS drops from ~100MB down to ~60MBs
I have no issues with QOS. The meters do not work right in Merlin or Asus firmware but the Adaptive QOS seems to work and improve buffer bloat scores on my 100/100 FIOS. This is a cosmetic Asus problem that will get fixed in time.I guess I'm really the outlier, I quess I could switch back to the AC86 that works with QOS without impacting internal LAN transfers, even though I lose faster wifi
Ahhh that... thanks for clarifying, me (nope don't care bout that)I have no issues with QOS. The meters do not work right in Merlin or Asus firmware but the Adaptive QOS seems to work and improve buffer bloat scores on my 100/100 FIOS. This is a cosmetic Asus problem that will get fixed in time.
Absolutely not.Do GT-AXE11000 and GT-AX11000 share the same firmware?
Adaptive QOS does not throttle LAN to LAN transfers only cake and traditional, the thing is though cake work best for my connection, gives me A+.This is VERY interesting to myself because... I am currently Transitioning from using a RT-AC68U & FlexQoS as my primary router + a single RT-AC68U Mesh Node... to using a RT-AX86U as Primary & likely using CAKE with one or two RT-AC68U Mesh Nodes. Anyways if you were using FlexQoS with Adaptive I would probably point out that you could probably make the NAS device a higher QoS class because as you described above... depending on what you were doing, wouldn't the device be correct in classifying the the NAS activity as file-transfer
Adaptive somethimes give me B or A depending on the test run with bufferbloat, but Cake always give me A+ on my 50 DL and10 UL. But the real issue is the impact Cake has of slowing LAN transfers to and from my NAS, and why this occurs on the AX86U and not the AC86U.I have no issues with QOS. The meters do not work right in Merlin or Asus firmware but the Adaptive QOS seems to work and improve buffer bloat scores on my 100/100 FIOS. This is a cosmetic Asus problem that will get fixed in time.
Welcome To SNBForums
SNBForums is a community for anyone who wants to learn about or discuss the latest in wireless routers, network storage and the ins and outs of building and maintaining a small network.
If you'd like to post a question, simply register and have at it!
While you're at it, please check out SmallNetBuilder for product reviews and our famous Router Charts, Ranker and plenty more!