[Beta] Asuswrt-Merlin 384.16 beta (and 384.13_5) are available

[joe scian]

Beta 2 working perfectly on AC-5300

 

[axaro1]

Beta 2, QoS still broken https://imgur.com/a/bb51edc

 

[eclp]

Beta 2, QoS still broken https://imgur.com/a/bb51edc

Have you already tried the test without activated QOS?

 

[MarkRH]

Beta 2, QoS still broken https://imgur.com/a/bb51edc

On my RT-AC68U I get an A bufferbloat without QoS on this firmware version. Worst I've ever had was B so I just never bothered with it. Suppose I should test with it just to see.

 

[octopus]

I have udated to beta2 and working fine.

Inadyn shold be 2.7 but it is:

Mar 23 07:13:57 inadyn[1238]: In-a-dyn version 2.6 -- Dynamic DNS update client.

 

[axaro1]

Have you already tried the test without activated QOS?

Yes, I tried with QoS OFF and the results aren't much different from the screenshots (except from random upload spikes up to 700/1500ms, but the average upload bufferbloat is still at 130-170ms)
I tried to limit the download/upload bandwith with different values but it's not making any difference, I get the same download upload whether I set it to 85/40 or 10/5.
I tried Traditional QoS but it cuts my download by 2/3.

 

[S.claus]

Beta 2, QoS still broken https://imgur.com/a/bb51edc

Upload isn't limiting that's all but only ASUS can fix their closed source code.

 

[Mrk26]

Yes, I tried with QoS OFF and the results aren't much different from the screenshots (except from random upload spikes up to 700/1500ms, but the average upload bufferbloat is still at 130-170ms)
I tried to limit the download/upload bandwith with different values but it's not making any difference, I get the same download upload whether I set it to 85/40 or 10/5.
I tried Traditional QoS but it cuts my download by 2/3.

Don't use adaptive QoS, use traditional instead and see if that works for you.

 

[eclp]

Just tested, without QoS (AX88U):

 

[axaro1]

Don't use adaptive QoS, use traditional instead and see if that works for you.

 

[Ozymandias]

RT-AX56U

Upgraded to beta2 without problem

Issue:
- USB2 connector shows no device attached (USB3 connector works correctly)

 

[axaro1]

RT-AX56U

Upgraded to beta2 without problem

Issue:
- USB2 connector shows no device attached (USB3 connector works correctly)

Have you tried the Adaptive QoS on your RT-AX56U? Is it correctly limiting your bandwith?

 

[MDM]

Smooth update to refreshed 384.13_5 on 87u
Thanks RMerlin
Tools/Sysinfo: Firmware Build= Sun Mar 22 19:49:31 UTC 2020 merlin@acc9bd1 (the refreshed 384.13_5)

(Old 384.13_5 Firmware Build= Sat Mar 14 17:49:57 UTC 2020 merlin@d36a34a)

Same, all is working as expected.

 

[Ozymandias]

Have you tried the Adaptive QoS on your RT-AX56U? Is it correctly limiting your bandwith?

I've never bothered with the Adaptive QoS up to now.
What's the easiest way to test if it is working?

 

[axaro1]

I've never bothered with the Adaptive QoS up to now.
What's the easiest way to test if it is working?

Enable Adaptive QoS, use Manual settings, select fq_codel and allocate 85/90% of your Download/Upload bandwith.
Then you can run https://www.dslreports.com/speedtest

 

[John Adler]

flashed dirty ß2 over ß1
all fine!
Thxs Merlin!

 

[Ozymandias]

Enable Adaptive QoS, use Manual settings, select fq_codel and allocate 85/90% of your Download/Upload bandwith.
Then you can run https://www.dslreports.com/speedtest

Enabling Adaptive QoS doesn't seem to make any difference in download or upload speed. I could see no reduction in speeds with it enabled.

 

[axaro1]

Enabling Adaptive QoS doesn't seem to make any difference in download or upload speed. I could see no reduction in speeds with it enabled.

That's exactly my problem, QoS fails to limit the bandwith.
I'm starting to think this issue might be specifically related to the RT-AX56U, I wonder if users who own the AX58U/AX3000 have this same issue.

 

[nmogas]

Beta 2, QoS still broken https://imgur.com/a/bb51edc

You have the upload/download bandwidth configured the other way around. Swap the values

 

[axaro1]

You have the upload/download bandwidth configured the other way around. Swap the values

I swapped the values:
I tried limiting download with 85-80-70-50, I keep getting 65-75 megabit/s with 10-60ms bufferbloat.
I tried limiting upload with 40-35-10 and I keep getting 33-48 megabit/s in download with an average 300-500ms bufferbloat.
I just tried 50/10 and dslreport result was 79.5/48.2